When this SQ unlocks
Carmen Dei Chapter Act I "Should You Be Trapped in a Windless Land" unlocks in patch 1.0 at Adventure Rank 36, after Klee's Trifolium Chapter Act I "True Treasure" (see Trifolium Chapter). [2] It has four parts: A Child's Secret, The South Wind Brings Adventure, Lionfang's Legacy, and Should You Be Trapped in a Windless Land.
The nirnama detector
The Outlander and Paimon see Nora laughing with someone who is not there. The Outlander admits they had an imaginary friend as a child ("We, uh, don't hang out anymore"), and when Paimon asks whether their sibling has one too, the answer is "Sure they do." [11]
Venti arrives with a monocle. It is a "nirnama detector," one of Lisa's new contraptions, for which "Lisa had to import some dangerous materials from Sumeru." Lisa "isn't able to use it herself," so Venti is borrowing it and testing it for her. He suggests she may lack "a certain childlike sense of wonder." Through it, the Outlander can see Nora's friend. [11]
A Child's Secret
Flora's friend is a Bloatty Floatty she calls "Mr. Floatty," a plant she likes because it can fly. She heard about the plant from the adventurer Stanley. Timmie's imaginary friend is a Ruin Guard, which sends Paimon into a panic. [11] At Angel's Share the adults have none. Kaeya needles Diluc about selling their father's mansion, and Diluc says that fifteen years earlier the device would still have found nothing on him. [11]
Ellin, who is training to become a knight, has Jean as her imaginary friend. Stanley's stories fired her up, and if she got to adventure with Jean herself, that would be "even better." After the Outlander helps her smash some training dummies, she asks them to tell her friend Jack, who is adventuring with Stanley at the Temple of the Lion, that she has to miss their meeting. [11]
The South Wind Brings Adventure
At the Temple of the Lion, a quest domain, Jack and Stanley are cornered by a Cryo Abyss Mage and hilichurls. [12] Stanley insists he could have handled it and introduces himself as "Stanley, who braved the Mare Jivari!" Jack recounts the legend: Stanley and his partner reached the Mare Jivari, "A famously terrifying place with not a wisp of wind!" [12] Venti asks the Outlander to use the detector on Stanley. He has an imaginary friend too, "a seasoned warrior... covered in scars from head to foot." [12]
After Stanley leaves, Jack shares a secret Stanley told him while drunk: the weapons Stanley carried were once wielded by Vennessa, "The Sword of Brilliant Valor and the Shield of Magnificent Honor," and both are still in Dadaupa Gorge. Jack's parents do not support his adventuring, and he hopes the weapons will change their minds. He offers Venti a bottle of "rare vintage wine," and Venti suddenly has time. [12]
Lionfang's Legacy
In Dadaupa Gorge, hilichurls are bowing to the "sword." Venti privately notes that someone "tossed an old sword into a pile of spoils," but when Jack's face falls, he talks him round with a speech about valor shining brightest in the dark. The "shield" is a piece of scrap wood with a handle, wine stains and all, in a hilichurl's hands, and Venti calls its battered state proof of honor. The Outlander either talks the hilichurl out of it or drives it off. [13]
Stanley has been following them. Jack runs home to show his parents without noticing him, Stanley claims to be out for a "stroll," and Paimon wonders whether he planted the weapons to spare Jack's feelings. Venti muses about "Someone who can't let go of the past, and gives up on the present instead..." and invites the Outlander to Angel's Share that night. [13]
Should You Be Trapped in a Windless Land
At the tavern, Stanley is drunk and talking to Stanley. "It should have been me! I should have been the one to die in the Mare Jivari that day... Why won't your spirit come and stop me from using your name?" [14] Venti works it out: "The real Stanley is the one who died to save our 'Stanley.'" [14]
Jack drops by to say his parents now support him, and leaves hoping for more stories tomorrow. With Jack gone, the man thanks them for keeping his secret. Jack's spirit is "so pure... unblemished," and he cannot let the boy's dreams be crushed. What haunts him is that his friend "died in a windless land, where his spirit can never be recovered!" Venti explains the scarred warrior in the detector: in the man's memory, the real Stanley is no longer "the living, breathing friend he knew at all," only the battle-scarred image he has held on to. [14]
Venti then speaks the man's real name, "Hans Archibald?", and raises a gentle breeze. "I can hear the wind blowing in the Mare Jivari..." Hans says. Venti shows himself as Barbatos and asks, "Will you hand me your old friend's spirit?" Hans lets go, thanks "Lord Barbatos," and says he thinks he is going to be okay. [14] Diluc, behind the bar, is confident "the people of Mondstadt will not forget his friend's story." [14] Fandom's Stanley page describes Hans as Stanley's companion on that trip, whom Stanley gave his life to save. [7]
At the statue
Venti goes to collect Jack's promised vintage, which turns out to be half a bottle of regular cider, and meets the Outlander at "the usual place," the Anemo Archon statue. [14] [2] The view takes him back to "about twenty-six hundred years ago, before the world had come under the rule of The Seven," when Old Mondstadt, now Stormterror's Lair, was ruled by "Decarabian, God of Storms," who sealed off the city with a ferocious hurricane. [14]
"Back then, I was but a wisp among the thousand winds. I wasn't a god of anything," Venti says, just a "tiny elemental being who lived in the wind." His current form, he tells Paimon, "is not so different from the situation with fake Stanley... I took the form of a friend." [14] In the cutscene that follows, he tells the Outlander about a young man of long ago, his songs and poems, and "the courage he showed in his fight for freedom." [14]
When Paimon asks what happened to that friend, the Outlander sends her off to fetch food. Venti takes it as the mark of a true friend ("true friends can tell what the other is thinking") and recalls a song he first heard from him: "Fly, fly away. Like a bird in the sky." [14] Fandom names the friend as the Nameless Bard, and its summary says the Outlander deduces that he died while freeing Mondstadt from Decarabian. Venti does not say this outright on-screen. [2] [5]
What the chapter confirms
Venti began as an elemental wisp with no human form, and his present form is the form of a friend. [14]
Decarabian, "God of Storms," ruled Old Mondstadt from the tower that is now Stormterror's Lair and walled the city in with a hurricane, about 2,600 years ago in Venti's telling. [14]
The man Mondstadt knows as Stanley is Hans Archibald, who took his dead partner's name to keep his stories alive. [14] [7]
Hans believes a death in the windless Mare Jivari leaves a spirit that "can never be recovered," and the quest resolves his case with a breeze raised by Barbatos. How this works in general is not explained. [14]
Venti reveals himself as Barbatos to Hans in a private moment, and Hans thanks "Lord Barbatos." The quest does not show anyone else learning it. [14]
What it holds back
- It does not show the Archon War. Decarabian's rule comes through Venti's account, and the friend's story through a song and a short cutscene.
- It does not name Boreas or the Four Winds.
- Vennessa's sword and shield are not what Jack thinks. Venti sees an old sword tossed onto a pile of spoils, and the shield is a piece of a wine barrel. Who left them there is unconfirmed; Paimon only suspects Stanley.
- Diluc and Kaeya appear briefly at Angel's Share, and Jean only as Ellin's imaginary friend.
Threads to follow
Venti and Decarabian cover the history behind Venti's story, and Mondstadt gives the regional context. Ellin's hero is the subject of Jean's Leo Minor Chapter - Act I "Master's Day Off", and Klee's Trifolium Chapter is the prerequisite.
