Act II belongs to Navia. With Lyney cleared in Act I, she and the Traveler reopen the case against her late father and follow it into the serial disappearances that hang over the Court of Fontaine. The trail leads to Marcel, whose real name is Vacher, and the act closes on a verdict nobody expects: the Oratrice Mecanique d'Analyse Cardinale finds Childe guilty. [1]
A voice in the fountain
After Lyney's acquittal, Navia treats the Traveler and Paimon to a meal at Hotel Debord. The trial has shown them that an organization is behind the disappearances, though its motives are unclear. That evening at the Fountain of Lucine the Traveler hears a voice calling for Vacher, blacks out, and finds themselves mentally linked to an Oceanid. She has lost most of her memories of life as a human, and the Traveler realises she was one of the girls who disappeared. She turns down the Traveler's offer to find Vacher and asks only this: "If you meet Vacher, tell him not to look for me. Tell him to move on." [1] [8]
When the Traveler comes to, Navia, Silver and Melus are fighting a whole army of Gardemeks, and Clorinde arrives in time to help. [9] The meka carry no serial numbers, so Clorinde takes them for a private force kept by someone rich or powerful. Navia then works out what happened at the hotel. The Fonta she was served, which Paimon drank by mistake, had been spiked with Primordial Seawater, so Paimon had foiled an attempt on Navia's life. The seawater also raised Paimon's sensitivity to Hydro, which is why she could hear the Oceanid too. [1] Primordial Seawater dissolves people from Fontaine, but in outsiders it only heightens that sensitivity. [5]
Callas and Clorinde
Navia explains why the case matters to her. Three years earlier her father, Callas, then head of the Spina di Rosula, was accused of murdering his friend Jacques. Rather than stand trial he chose a duel, and he died in it, refusing to yield. Melus reveals that the duelist who killed him was Clorinde, and that at the start of the duel Callas had asked her to keep Navia safe. [1] [8]
Neuvillette's case archives at the Palais Mermonia hold nothing on anyone named Vacher. When he offers his regrets over Callas, Navia hears no feeling in it and rounds on him for letting the duel go ahead. Outside, a sudden rain starts. Navia remembers that it also rained the night Jacques was killed, and the Traveler sees that the real killer might have been turned into water, with the rain washing away any trace. Back in Poisson, Navia ties her father's case to Sinthe, a drink that caught on in Poisson years ago and that she is now "almost certain" was made with Primordial Seawater. Long use brought harmful side effects. Callas, who oversaw Poisson, called for a complete ban, and Jacques, a dealer ashamed of the families Sinthe had destroyed, became his informant. Clothes left at the scene point to a third person. [1] [8]
Melus then shares what Callas kept from his daughter. Callas had been diagnosed with a rare illness and told he had no more than five years to live, and the people behind Sinthe had picked Navia as the next woman to "disappear." To protect her, Callas claimed to hold key evidence against them that would come out if anything happened to her, and they had not moved against her since. Melus has narrowed his suspects to three: Florent, the Spina's senior adviser; Thierry, who handles its dealings with the Gardes; and Marcel, head of the Confrerie of Cabriere. After questioning all three, Navia and the Traveler see that only Marcel has the money for a private force of meka. Then Thierry brings word that a Fatui Harbinger, Tartaglia, whom the Traveler knows as Childe, is on trial at the opera house as the culprit behind the disappearances. [1] [8]
Marcel is Vacher
The Traveler slips into the underwater Sinthe production facility while Navia goes to the opera house, where Childe is on trial, to accuse Marcel and stall for time. Clorinde testifies for Callas: "I hereby swear on my name and honor as a Champion Duelist that Mr. Callas never intended to leave the Ring alive." Marcel nearly turns the court in his favor by pointing out that the disappearances began before he ever set foot in Fontaine, until Navia mentions Vacher, which catches him off guard. Inside the facility, the Traveler finds experiment reports signed by Vacher and the diary of his lover, Vigneire. It has a page of crossed-out baby names, and the one she finally chose is "Marcel." [1] [8]
Back in court the Traveler names Marcel as Vacher. He does not defend himself. He blames the system instead: "All those decades ago, even the officers from the Maison Gardiennage were laughing at me..." He and Vigneire had promised to stay together, but he is not from Fontaine and cannot be dissolved to follow her, and he drinks Primordial Seawater on the stand to show it. Neuvillette then sums up the case. Vacher and Vigneire were adventurers, and she was dissolved in front of him by Primordial Seawater on an underwater expedition. He kidnapped young women for research in the hope of bringing her back, took the name Marcel, sold diluted seawater as Sinthe, and made Callas look like a murderer by dissolving the assassin he had sent to the banquet. The Oratrice finds him guilty. [1] [7] [8]
Afterwards Marcel begs to know where the Traveler heard the name Vacher, and Neuvillette takes him to the Fountain of Lucine himself. There the voice tells Marcel it is not Vigneire but the "sacrifices," the merged consciousness of the women he dissolved: "The only one I am not... is Vigneire." It says the first message, not to look for her, came from the real Vigneire, who wants nothing more to do with him. Then it tells him to "Drown." Later, "the final report from the physicians states that he died of a massive fright." [6] [8] [5]
Childe's verdict
With Marcel convicted, Neuvillette says the charges against Childe "no longer have any basis." Court protocol still requires a verdict on the original charge, so his case goes to the Oratrice too. It finds him "Guilty," and the audience gasps that the Oratrice has never before returned a different verdict from the Chief Justice. When Gardemeks come to take him, Childe fights them with his Delusion and starts his Foul Legacy transformation, but Neuvillette leaps down from his seat and subdues him, telling him, "If you have been wronged, we will find the truth." Everyone then turns to Furina. She first says she had nothing to do with it, then claims the whole scene was a planned performance and the Oratrice's verdict correct, and leaves. Neuvillette promises to keep investigating in a personal capacity. [1] [6] [8]
A few days later Navia holds a belated memorial for her father, whose honor has been restored, and makes amends with Clorinde. At Callas's grave, Neuvillette explains why he let the duel go ahead: "I believed that a truly innocent man would never throw away his life like that." Callas, he says, "proved me utterly and decisively wrong." [1] [8]
The Traveler then puts some questions to him. He has long known that the Oratrice "does not simply mechanically repeat the verdict that I give on each case," and he has been prepared for a situation like Childe's for a long time. For now, he says, the Harbinger "will just have to bide his time in the Fortress of Meropide." Of the prophecy going around Fontaine, he says rumor traces it to the last words of the former Hydro Archon, that two parts of it, the rising sea levels and the dissolving of Fontaine's people, have already come true, and that Furina "has also always taken it quite seriously." Why the Primordial Sea, which nurtured life, should dissolve Fontainians, he cannot explain. [6] The Fortress of Meropide is Fontaine's underwater prison, run by its Administrator, Wriothesley, who does not appear in this act. [4] [3]
Who investigates in Fontaine
The investigation in this act is Navia's, run with Silver and Melus of the Spina di Rosula. The official side is the Maison Gardiennage, whose officers, the Gardes, keep order in Fontaine alongside the Gardemeks. [1] [7] Neuvillette, the Iudex, also leads the Marechaussee Phantom, Fontaine's special detective force, which is mostly made up of Melusines, though it plays no part in this act. The Marechaussee Hunters were an older group of monster hunters and no longer exist as an organized group. [2]
What carries forward
Childe's verdict is the act's open question. The Oratrice and the Iudex disagree for the first time, Furina's reaction is strange, and Neuvillette promises to keep investigating Childe's case. Navia's case, by contrast, is closed: Callas's name is cleared and Vacher is dead. [1]
The story before this act is in Prelude of Blancheur and Noirceur, and it continues in To the Stars Shining in the Depths and Cataclysm's Quickening. The main figures have their own pages: Navia, Clorinde, Neuvillette, Childe and Furina.

