The Five Sinners of Khaenri'ah are five pre-Cataclysm Khaenri'ahns: Rhinedottir, Vedrfolnir, Surtalogi, Hroptatyr, and Rerir. They divided among themselves the world-shattering Abyssal power King Irmin had the Traveler's Sibling absorb, on the night Dainsleif convened a raid to free his older brother from Irmin's prison. Dainsleif named all five in Bedtime Story (Version 4.7), and Song of the Welkin Moon Act IV, "An Elegy for Faded Moonlight" (Version Luna II, 6.1), staged the night they became Sinners. [1] [19] [2]
They are not Shades or Sovereigns. They are Khaenri'ahns who acquired transcendent Abyssal power by theft, and who abandoned Khaenri'ah to its fate in the bargain. None of the five defended the kingdom when the Cataclysm came. [4] Capitano, who bears the curse of immortality, says the people of Khaenri'ah "committed grave sins, and for that we were cursed," yet "most of us knew nothing of the Five Sinners' exploitation of Abyssal power." His words imply that the curse answered the Sinners' actions, which most of those cursed knew nothing about. [3] [23]
The framework - what the Five Sinners are
The Five Sinners are a category defined after the event, not an institution that already existed. Before the raid, Rhinedottir calls Hroptatyr "by far the most favored among the Four Pillars of Khaenri'ah." The scene does not name the other Pillars, and whether other future Sinners were among them is unconfirmed. Rerir was further from the court. By Dainsleif's account he was "just an ordinary man, working for the Khaenri'ahn intelligence service," and per Welkin Moon Act III "Everlasting As the Moon" his job was to hunt down and assassinate the remaining Crimson Moon Dynasty descendants under Irmin's suppression order. His fiancée Tholindis was a distant Crimson Moon descendant, and when her file reached his desk he broke with the king. He joined Dainsleif's raid wanting only "a letter of pardon," which Nefer guesses was meant for Tholindis. That night he watched her vanish through a portal she had opened in her lab, then went back to the palace and split the Abyssal power "alongside the other four members." Rerir's path into the group runs through a dispute between the Eclipse and Crimson Moon dynasties, not through anything the Sinners themselves represented. [20] [16] [21] [14] [17] [18]
The category they occupy is unlike any other power in Teyvat. They are not Sovereigns (pre-human draconic rulers), not Shades (the governing infrastructure the Heavenly Principles created), not Descenders (offworld arrivals), and not Archons. They are Khaenri'ahns wielding stolen Abyssal power, a category the canon does not name apart from the name Five Sinners itself. That is why it matters to keep Surtalogi separate from the Cryo Sovereign, as set out below.
The Vedrfolnir-rescue origin event
Per the memory dive in Welkin Moon Act IV All Is Foretold, the founding event ran as follows. Vedrfolnir, Dainsleif's older brother, a prophet, and one of Irmin's most trusted council members alongside Hroptatyr, had warned Irmin that Khaenri'ah would fall if Irmin continued down his path. Irmin gouged out Vedrfolnir's eyes and threw him into a decrepit cell. Dainsleif, a knight Captain of the Royal Guard at the time and Vedrfolnir's younger brother, convened a five-person extraction with Rhinedottir, Surtalogi, Hroptatyr, and Rerir, the intelligence officer who had just turned against Irmin's purge. [2] [13]
Dainsleif's group, Surtalogi among them, fought the troops in the palace, Rhinedottir and Hroptatyr disarmed its security measures, and Rerir broke Vedrfolnir out of his cell. In the course of that night the power Irmin had the Sibling absorb, deep beneath the kingdom, was divided: by Hroptatyr, Rhinedottir, Surtalogi, and Rerir, and by Vedrfolnir, the man they had come to save. Dainsleif's own words are that the five "divided among themselves a power that could destroy the world." Skirk's character story speaks of the division as "enough Abyssal power amongst yourselves to overturn an entire world — or at least a sixth of it," usually read as one sixth per Sinner. In Natlan, the Abyss Order's Haden says only that "the great Abyssal power within" the Sibling "had been divided up." No source says what became of any remaining share. [20] [10] [21] [19] [26] [1] [24]
Dainsleif convened the operation but took no share, so he is the organizer who never became a Sinner. The name covers only the five who took the power. "Even Vedrfolnir — the very person I had come to rescue — abandoned me and partook of the Abyss's power," he says. [2] [20]
Welkin Moon Act IV also stages the voice in Rerir's head. Rerir becomes sure it is Vedrfolnir's, and Nefer's retelling calls it "Vedrfolnir's voice." In the cell, though, Vedrfolnir denies it and laughs: "So, you hear it too." Only those two are shown hearing such a voice. Dainsleif says more broadly that the Sinners were each driven by their own desires, and "it was by playing upon these that the Abyss tempted them to their fall." [20]
The 5/5 framework
Dainsleif names all five in Bedtime Story: "'The Wise' Hroptatyr, 'The Visionary' Vedrfolnir, 'Gold' Rhinedottir, 'The Foul' Surtalogi, and 'Rächer of Solnari' Rerir." Their known states as of Version 7.2: [19]
Sinner | Title / Mark | State as of 7.2 | Weapon |
|---|---|---|---|
Rhinedottir | "Gold" - alchemist | Created Durin and Albedo. Fused with Naberius per AQ Interlude Chapter Act IV "Paralogism" (5.6). In Chapter VII she is the Ruler of Life, and in Act IV (7.1) she meets the Tsaritsa at Zapolyarny Palace. | Serpent Devourer (once "Logseims") |
Vedrfolnir | "The Visionary" - prophet whose imprisonment triggered the operation | Heard as a voice from a chained crystal in a post-Cataclysm memory in AQ III Act VI "Caribert," and seen watching through Roland's memory in Varka's Story Quest Act I. Surtalogi says Vedrfolnir told him he was destined to find a disciple "out there in the universe," the origin of Skirk's recruitment. In 7.1 Pierro attributes Hroptatyr's "crowned heir" prophecy to him. | Hallowed Fetters (once "Gleipnir") |
Surtalogi | "The Foul" - Skirk's master | Departed Teyvat post-Cataclysm; travels the Sea of Stars in search of an opponent who could best him; took Skirk as his disciple per Vedrfolnir's prophecy. A Khaenri'ahn Sinner, not the Cryo Sovereign; see the disambiguation below and his character page. | Starpiercer (once "Gusisnautar") |
Hroptatyr | "The Wise" - President of the Universitas Magistrorum and Chief Royal Mage | Left Teyvat after the Cataclysm to "merge with the Abyss to acquire infinite knowledge," leaving Pierro a notebook on research he named "The Curse of Immortality." Pierro says Hroptatyr summoned the Traveler's sibling. Present whereabouts unknown. See his character page. | Ardent Storm (once "Starkuthr") |
Rerir | "Rächer of Solnari" - Wild Hunt commander | Before becoming a Sinner, Rerir was an ordinary intelligence officer under King Irmin, secretly assigned to hunt Crimson Moon descendants. He was not an aristocrat. He later took a share of stolen Abyssal power and commanded the Wild Hunt. In Song of the Welkin Moon Act VIII, Columbina meets him inside the moon's reflection. | Shattered Moon (once "Barnstokkr") |
Each of the five Stygian Onslaught weapon appearances points to one Sinner through its description, which names the weapon's old wielder only by epithet: "wise sinner" for Ardent Storm, "an oracle-issuing sinner" for Hallowed Fetters, "a golden sinner" for Serpent Devourer, "a moon-hunting sinner" for Shattered Moon, and "a foul sinner" for Starpiercer. [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [11] [27] [22] [34]
Cataclysm-non-defence and the Ronova-curse mechanism
The Five Sinners' relationship to the Cataclysm rests on two primary-text disclosures. First, none of the five defended Khaenri'ah. In Bedtime Story, Dainsleif says, "when the cataclysm occurred, not one of them stood up in defense of their nation." He also names them as the defenders who should have been: "The six of us, together... We should have been the ones to prevent the disaster, the ones to stop the Vinster King from continuing to rock the foundation of the world." [4] [19]
Second, Capitano's disclosure in AQ V Act V Part 5 "When All Becomes a Monument" connects the curse to them. He blames Ronova for "the curse of immortality, the curse of absolute life," and says most of those cursed "knew nothing of the Five Sinners' exploitation of Abyssal power." In Chapter VII Act IV the Traveler concludes that the Curse of Immortality "was a permanent curse placed by Ronova under the judgment of the Heavenly Principles." The same act reveals that Hroptatyr had used the name "The Curse of Immortality" for his own research into the Crimson Moon's authority over death; it does not say whether the two are connected. [3] [23] [27] [28] [15]
The Five Sinners' powers and later outcomes came from taking Abyssal power, not from curses that Heaven passed on each of them. Full-blooded Khaenri'ahns such as Dainsleif and Pierro carry the curse of immortality; in Act IV Dainsleif blames Ronova for inflicting it on him, and Mitya senses the same curse on Pierro. Eide separately says people whose ancestry belonged to the domains of other gods received the curse of the wilderness and became monsters, with Caribert as the direct hilichurl case; that text does not assign Abyss Mages, Heralds, or Lectors to any bloodline. [27] [8]
Is Surtalogi the Cryo Sovereign? (No)
The Sinners are not Sovereigns. Sovereigns are pre-human draconic rulers who held elemental authority by birthright before the Heavenly Principles arrived. Sinners are Khaenri'ahns who acquired Abyssal power by theft 500 years ago. The two belong to different ages of the world, one before the Heavenly Principles arrived and one after.
Surtalogi is a Khaenri'ahn Sinner, not the Cryo Sovereign. Skirk's Cryo presentation is a Seven-Shifting Serpent disguise over Abyssal substance. Version 7.0 establishes that the unnamed original Cryo Sovereign is dead; no current successor is known. [7] [12] [36]
Where the five went after the Cataclysm
After the Cataclysm the five went separate ways. Surtalogi offered to break his friend Skofnungr's curse of immortality and left Teyvat for the stars. Hroptatyr found Pierro in the ruins, handed him the notebook, and left to merge with the Abyss. Rerir, as the Rächer of Solnari, drove the Wild Hunt in Nod-Krai, and Columbina later meets him inside the moon's reflection. Vedrfolnir has been heard as a voice and seen as an eye in others' memories. Rhinedottir merged with Naberius and appears in Chapter VII as the Ruler of Life. [25] [27] [20] [22] [8] [9] [6]
Skirk compares only her master and Rhinedottir as "both pursuing some form of perfection." No released source, through Chapter VII Act VI, shows the five acting together after the Cataclysm. [5] [35] [38]
Connected pages
- Surtalogi - Skirk's master, and the figure it is important not to confuse with the Cryo Sovereign.
- Hroptatyr - "The Wise," whose notebook and departure are the subject of Chapter VII Act IV.
- Vedrfolnir - "The Visionary," Dainsleif's brother.
- Irmin - the last Vinster King, whose Abyssal ambitions set the stage.
- Khaenri'ah - the kingdom they came from.
- The Cataclysm - the disaster that followed, and the curses laid on Khaenri'ah's survivors.
- The Abyss - the source of the power they divided.
- Four Shades - Ronova, who laid the curse of immortality, and Naberius, now fused with Rhinedottir.
- Seven Sovereigns - a wholly different kind of power; the mismatch between Sinner and Sovereign is why Surtalogi cannot be the Cryo Sovereign.
- Descenders - another distinct category of being.
- Dainsleif - the organizer who took no share and so never became a Sinner.
- Crimson Moon Dynasty and Crimson-Moon-blooded - the older of Khaenri'ah's two ruling dynasties, plus the bloodline of its descendants. Rerir's pre-Sinner job was hunting Crimson Moon descendants for Irmin, and his fiancée Tholindis was one of them.
What canon has not surfaced
- Where Hroptatyr went. Pierro reports his plan to merge with the Abyss; no released source shows what became of him.
- Whether Hroptatyr's Curse of Immortality research is connected to the curse Ronova laid on Khaenri'ah. The shared name invites the link; Chapter VII Act IV does not make it.
- The voice's source. Rerir and Nefer's retelling attribute the voice in Rerir's head to Vedrfolnir, who denies it. Whether it was his, the Sibling's, or the Abyss speaking remains open.
- Any remaining share. Skirk's "a sixth of it" suggests five shares of six, but no source says whether a portion remained or who holds it.
- How the Sinners' powers compare. The canon does not rank the five against each other.
- The Sinners' role later in Chapter VII. Acts I-VI do not pull the five back together. Act IV brings Rhinedottir to the Tsaritsa's palace and revisits Hroptatyr only through his notebook and a memory, and Act V touches on Rhinedottir only in passing, if she is the "Rhine" who Alice says "had already filled me in on the backstory." [37]
The Five Sinners are the five Khaenri'ahns who, on the night Dainsleif freed his brother, divided the Abyssal power their king had the Traveler's Sibling absorb. They became transcendent, and none of them defended their kingdom when the Cataclysm came. Dainsleif was there and took no share. Capitano's words imply that the curse on Khaenri'ahns answered what the Sinners did, though most of those cursed knew nothing of it.
Skirk's master has a full biography on the Surtalogi page and the Wise on the Hroptatyr page. The primary-text staging of the raid is Welkin Moon Act IV, and the broader narrative runs through the essay Khaenri'ah, the Cataclysm, and 500 years after.
